中国实用妇科与产科杂志

• 专题笔谈 • 上一篇    下一篇

阴道植入网片与自体组织修补的临床效果比较

  

  1. 中国人民解放军总医院第四医学中心,北京 100048
  • 出版日期:2020-10-02 发布日期:2020-10-22
  • 通讯作者: 鲁永鲜

Comparison of clinical effect between transvaginal mesh and vaginal native tissue repair in the treatment of pelvic organ prolapse.

  1. Fourth Medical Center,Chinese PLA General Hospital,Beijing 100048,China
  • Online:2020-10-02 Published:2020-10-22

摘要: 文章对近年来发表的经阴道植入网片(transvaginal mesh,TVM)与经阴道自体组织修补(vaginal native tissue repair,VNTR)治疗盆腔器官脱垂(pelvic organ prolapsed,POP)的文献结果进行了比较。结果显示:(1)两组围手术期及短期并发症以Clavien-Dindo外科并发症严重程度分级系统进行评价,提示网片短期严重并发症并不常见,TVM与VNTR一样安全。(2)两组在近中期主客观效果、复发率、网片重量及对性功能影响方面比较,除一项研究外,多数研究结果表明TVM组患者术后脱垂感知率、前壁脱垂复发率和再次手术率方面都要低于VNTR组,虽然网片独特并发症增加了再次手术率,但两组总体再次手术率无显著差异。轻质网片并发症少于重质网片。两组在性交痛发生率比较也无显著差异。(3)两组术后长期疗效比较,TVM组在阴道前壁和多腔室脱垂治疗方面主客观效果及满意度方面优于VNTR组,且减少了解剖学上的复发率。研究结果显示TVM是治疗POP的一种安全有效术式。适应证选择恰当和训练有素的医生可进一步降低TVM的并发症。

关键词: 经阴道植入网片, 经阴道自体组织修补, 盆腔器官脱垂, 并发症

Abstract: The aim of this commentary is to compare the clinical outcomes between transvaginal mesh(TVM)and vaginal native tissue repair(VNTR)for pelvic organ prolapsed(POP)in the literatures published recently.The results are as follows:(1)Clavien-Dindo classifications to assess the perioperative and short-term  serious complications of TVM and VNTR groups have shown that the early serious complicatios are rare in TVM group and TVM is as safe as VNTR.(2)Comparing the objective and subjective outcomes,recurrence rates,mesh weight and changes in sexual function between two groups of TVM and VNTR in near and medium-term follow-up,except one study,most studies have shown that TVM group is lower than VNTR group in terms of awareness of prolapse after operation,recurrence rates of anterior prolapse and repeat surgery rates.The specific complications caused by TVM has increased the repeat surgery rates,but the overall repeat surgery rates were of no significant difference  between the two groups.The low weight mesh has shown less complication than the heavy mesh.Dysparenia could  result from both TVM and VNTR groups and there was no significant difference  between the two groups.(3)Comparing the long-term outcomes after POP repair between the two groups,TVM  group has better  objective and subjective outcomes and satisfaction rates in anterior and multicompartment prolapse than VNTR group,and the anatomical recurrence rates are reduced.The study results indicate TVM is a safe and efficient option for POP surgical management.Low rates of mesh conmplications can be achieved with appropriate indications and trained surgeons.

Key words: transvaginal mesh, TVM;vaginal native tissue repair, VNTR;pelvic organ prolapsed, POP;complications

中图分类号: